“We need to go viral on TikTok.” This is the brief every agency receives from the CMO in 2025. It is usually the wrong goal. Reach is a drug. It feels good (Dopamine). It looks good on a report (Vanity Metrics). But Reach is cheap. You can buy 1 million impressions on Facebook for $5,000. Depth is hard. You cannot buy a “True Fan”. You have to earn them.

For a mass-market brand selling $5 toothpaste (Colgate), Reach is King. You need to hit 100 million people to make the math work. For a Luxury Brand selling $500 goods (Maison Code), Depth is King. You don’t need millions of followers. You need a Cult.

Why Maison Code Discusses This

We build Membership Systems. We are the engineers behind the “Login” button. Most brands treat the “My Account” page as a utility (Order History). We treat it as a Clubhouse. If your digital experience for a logged-in VIP customer is the same as for a random guest, you have failed. We discuss this because technology is the enabler of retention. You cannot have a “Community” if you don’t have a platform where they can exist.

1. The Math of 1,000 True Fans

In 2008, Kevin Kelly wrote the most important essay in internet history: “1,000 True Fans”. The theory: To be a successful creator/brand, you don’t need to be famous. You just need 1,000 people who will buy everything you produce.

The Math:

If you have 1,000 True Fans.
And you extract $100 profit per fan per year.
Total Profit: $100,000 / year.

For a luxury brand, let’s adjust the LTV (Lifetime Value):

1,000 True Fans.
$1,000 profit per fan per year (2 bags + accessories).
Total Profit: $1,000,000 / year.

You have a million-dollar EBITDA business with a customer base that can fit inside a high school gym. This is the Micro-Luxury model. It is antifragile. Even if Instagram changes its algorithm, your email list of 1,000 fans remains. You are immune to platform risk.

2. The Funnel vs The Flywheel

The traditional marketing funnel is Leaky.

Top: Awareness (1,000,000)
Middle: Consideration (10,000)
Bottom: Purchase (100) You spend millions filling the top bucket, only to lose 99.9% of people. This is inefficient capital allocation.

The Community Flywheel is circular.

Attract: Niche content attracts specific people.
Engage: You talk with them, not at them.
Delight: The product exceeds expectations.
Advocate: The customer tells 2 friends.
Repeat: The customer buys again.

In the Funnel, the customer is an output. In the Flywheel, the customer is an input. Your goal is to increase the velocity of the flywheel.

3. The Attention Graph: Narrowcasting

Social Media algorithms (TikTok/Reels) optimize for Broad Appeal. To go viral, you must make content that appeals to everyone. Content that appeals to everyone is, by definition, Generic. Luxury is Specific. Luxury creates distance. It excludes people. “If you don’t get it, it’s not for you.”

The Trap: If you post a generic “Outfit Transition” video, you might get 1M views. But those 1M people are not your customer. They are bored teenagers. If you post a 10-minute video about “The artisanal tanning process of Italian Leather”, you might get 1,000 views. But those 1,000 people are aficionados. They are the ones who will pay $500.

Strategy: Narrowcasting. Optimize for “Saves” and “Shares” (Utility/Status), not “Likes” (Reflex). Create content that is “Too long, too technical, too niche” for the algorithm. That is where the True Fans live. Substack is the perfect medium for this (Long-form Depth).

4. Building Cults (The Mechanics of Depth)

How do you deepen the relationship? You take them off rented land.

1. Owned Channels (The Inner Circle)

Instagram is a rented apartment. Zuckerberg is the landlord. He can evict you (ban) or raise the rent (ads). Move your VIPs to an owned house.

SMS (Community): Not “Buy this now” texts. “Hey, what color should we make next?” texts.
Discord/Geneva: A real-time chat room where fans talk to each other.
The Founder’s Email: A weekly letter from the Founder. Personal. Vulnerable.

2. Co-Creation (Zero Party Data)

(See Zero Party Data). Ask them to design the product. “We are debating between Gold or Silver hardware. Vote now.” When they vote, they invest social capital. When the product launches, they buy it because they helped build it. This is the IKEA Effect.

3. Rituals and Tokenism

Cults have rituals.

The Drop: Every Friday at 10 AM.
The Language: Specific terms only insiders know.
The Badge: A physical or digital token of membership.
- Example: A digital collectible (NFT without the jargon) that grants access to a secret shop.
- Example: A physical metal card sent to top 1% spenders.

5. The Cost of Virality (The Icarus Paradox)

Going viral can actually kill a luxury brand. If a niche brand suddenly blows up on TikTok (“The Amazon Dupe!”), thousands of mainstream customers flood in.

Operations fail: Stockouts, shipping delays.
Quality drops: Factory rushes production.
The Cool Factor dies:
- The “True Fans” (Adopters) see the “Normies” wearing it.
- “It’s too basic now.”
- They leave.
The Trend dies: The viral crowd moves to the next trend.
The Crash: You are left with no True Fans and no Viral Fans. Bankruptcy.

Sustainable growth is slow. It allows Operations and Culture to keep pace. Hermès grows 7% a year. Every year. For 100 years.

6. Measuring Depth: The New KPIs

Stop reporting “Impressions” to your Board. Report Love.

Repeat Purchase Rate (RPR): Target > 40%. This proves the product is good.
UGC Ratio: (Number of tagged posts / Number of orders). If 10% of customers post a photo unprompted, you are winning. This measures Pride.
Net Promoter Score (NPS): “Would you recommend us?”
LTV:CAC Ratio: If your LTV is $1000 and CAC is $100, you have a money printing machine (10:1 Ratio).

7. The Sovereign Territory: Email and SMS

If Instagram disappears tomorrow, do you still have a business? For 90% of brands, the answer is “No”. This is an unacceptable risk. You are building your castle on sand. Email is the only channel you own. It is an open protocol. No algorithm decides if your email gets delivered (mostly). Your goal should be to move every follower from “Rented Land” (Social) to “Sovereign Land” (Email/SMS).

The Exchange Rate:

1 Instagram Follower = $0.10 EV.
1 Email Subscriber = $10.00 EV.
1 SMS Subscriber = $25.00 EV.

Stop optimizing for followers. Optimize for the “migration rate” of followers to subscribers. Gate your best content. “Join the Inner Circle to get the full report.” This filters for the True Fans.

8. The Community Manager

The most important hire in 2026 is not the “Performance Marketer”. It is the Community Manager. This person does not run ads. They sit in the Discord. They reply to DMs. They send handwritten notes. They are the “Host” of the party. Do not outsource this to an agency. The community must feel the founder’s DNA.

8. Conclusion

Don’t widen the funnel. Deepen the funnel. Focus on the customer who already bought from you. The next sale from an existing customer is the most profitable revenue you can generate. Love your 1,000 fans. Ignore the millions. In a world of noise, signal is valuable. Be the signal.

Chasing vanity metrics?

Is your marketing team celebrating “Likes” while sales are flat? We build Retention Operating Systems and Loyalty Architectures.

Hire our Architects.