We recently audited a potential client. They were doing $10M in revenue. They had 47 Shopify Apps installed. They had three different popup apps (only one was active). They had two review platforms because “migration was hard.” They had a loyalty program that didn’t talk to their email platform. This is the Frankenstein Stack. It is stitched together with hope and duct tape. It is slow. It is expensive. And it is fragile. This article explains how to audit your stack and architect a Unified Commerce ecosystem.

Why Maison Code Discusses This

We are not just “Coders”. We are “Systems Architects”. We see CEOs signing contracts for flashy new SaaS tools without asking: “Does this plug into our existing data?” The result is Data Silos.

The Marketing Team thinks LTV is $50 (based on GA4).
The Finance Team thinks LTV is $80 (based on ERP).
The Support Team thinks LTV is $20 (based on Helpdesk). No one agrees. We discuss Integration Strategy because Bad Architecture = Bad Data = Bad Decisions. We turn the Frankenstein into a Machine.

1. The Audit Process (The Marie Kondo Method)

The first step is a ruthless audit.

Identify: List every tool you pay for. (Check the credit card statement).
Verify Usage: Log into the admin panel. When was the last time someone logged in? If > 3 months, Kill It.
Verify Connection: Does this tool send data back to the Single Source of Truth (Shopify/ERP)?
Consolidate:
- Can Klaviyo do SMS? Yes. Then why are you paying for Attentive?
- Can Shopify do Bundles? Yes. Why pay for ReCharge/Bold?
- Can Gorgias handle Instagram DMs? Yes. Why use a separate social tool? Goal: Reduce the stack size by 30%. Every app you remove improves Site Speed and reduces Security Risk.

2. The “Single Source of Truth” (SSOT)

In a Frankenstein stack, every app thinks it is the master.

Mailchimp thinks it owns the user record.
Salesforce thinks it owns the user record.
Shopify thinks it owns the user record. When a user updates their email, who wins? Architecture Rule #1: Define the SSOT. For most D2C brands, Shopify (or the ERP) is the SSOT for Orders and Customers. All other apps are “Slaves”. They read from Shopify. They write to Shopify. They do not hoard data.

3. The API Economy (Rest vs GraphQL)

(See API Layer). Integration relies on APIs (Application Programming Interfaces).

REST: The old standard. “Give me User 123”. Server sends User 123.
GraphQL: The modern standard. “Give me User 123’s email and last order total”. GraphQL allows for “Data Minimization”. You fetch only what you need. This is faster and cheaper. When choosing a new SaaS tool, ask the CTO: “Do they have a GraphQL API?” If the answer is No, think twice. They are living in 2015.

4. Middleware: The Glue

Sometimes, App A cannot talk to App B directly. You need Middleware.

The Amateur Way: Zapier. (Good for prototyping, bad for scale. Expensive and opaque).
The Pro Way: iPaaS (Integration Platform as a Service).
- Tools like Celigo, Mulesoft, or Workato.
- They handle “Retries” (What if the API is down?).
- They handle “Rate Limits” (Don’t crash the ERP).
- They provide logs. Middleware is the traffic cop. It ensures data flows smoothly without crashes.

5. Build vs Buy (The Eternal Question)

(See Build vs Buy). Should you buy a “Returns Management App” (Loop Returns) or build a custom portal? The Matrix:

Is it Core to your IP?
- Is your “Returns Process” unique? Does it define your brand?
- Yes -> Build it.
- No (It’s standard) -> Buy it.
Is the App Ecosystem mature?
- Are there great apps? -> Buy.
- Are the apps terrible? -> Build. For 90% of features (Reviews, Chat, Loyalty), Buy is the answer. Don’t reinvent the wheel. Reinvent the engine.

6. Headless Architecture (The Ultimate Separation)

(See Why Headless). In a Monolith (Standard Shopify Theme), the “Frontend” and “Backend” are glued together. If you install an App, it injects code directly into your Frontend. This slows down the site. In Headless, the Frontend is separate (React). Apps connect via API. They cannot “inject” slow code. They are chemically separated. This is the ultimate hygiene for a tech stack. It prevents “Plugin Bloat” from killing your Conversion Rate.

7. Data Warehousing (The Lake)

Where does all the data go? You need a Data Warehouse (Snowflake, BigQuery). Extract data from Shopify, Facebook, Google Ads, Klaviyo. Load it into BigQuery. Transform it. Visualize it in Looker Studio / Tableau. This allows you to ask complex questions: “Who are my most profitable customers who bought Shoes in July and came from Instagram?” Shopify Analytics cannot answer that. SQL can. (See Attribution SQL).

8. Real-Time vs Batched

Legacy systems used “Batch Processing”. “Every night at 12 AM, we sync the inventory.” In 2025, this is unacceptable. If I buy the last item at 11:59 PM, and you buy it at 12:01 AM… we have an oversell. You must move to Event-Driven Architecture (Webhooks).

Event: Order Created.
Action: Update Inventory (Immediately). Real-time data prevents customer service nightmares.

9. Security Risks of Fragmentation

Every app you install is a backdoor. If you give “Read/Write” access to a random “Free Shipping Bar” app built by a teenager in a basement… And that app gets hacked… The hacker has access to your customer data. Vendor Risk Management:

Limit permissions. (Does a Shipping Bar need access to Customer Addresses? No).
Review OAuth scopes.
Use “App Proxies” to hide sensitive keys. (See Vendor Risk).

10. Composable Commerce vs Monolith

The industry is buzzing about “Composable”. This means choosing the “Best of Breed” for every function.

CMS: Contentful.
Search: Algolia.
Cart: Shopify.
Review: Yotpo. This is powerful, but dangerous. The Monolith (All-in-One): Easier to manage. 90% of brands should stay here. Composable: Infinite flexibility, infinite complexity. Only for brands doing >$50M GMV. Don’t buy a Ferrari if you don’t have a mechanic team.

11. The Cost of Maintenance (Technical Debt)

Every app you add has a “Tax”. It is not just the monthly subscription fee. It is the Maintenance Fee.

Who updates the API keys when they expire?
Who fixes the integration when Shopify updates their API?
Who monitors the logs? If you have 47 apps, you need a full-time engineer just to keep the lights on. Strategy: Calculate TCO (Total Cost of Ownership). Software Fee + Maintenance Hours = Real Cost. Simplify the stack to lower the tax.

11. Documentation as Culture

In a Frankenstein stack, knowledge lives in one person’s head. “Ask Bob how the loyalty points sync.” If Bob leaves, the company is paralyzed. The Fix: Notion/Confluence. Document every integration. “Field A in Shopify maps to Field B in Salesforce.” documentation is not an afterthought. It is an asset. (See 100 Year Brand).

12. Conclusion

A Clean Stack is a Competitive Advantage. It allows you to move fast. It allows you to trust your data. It allows your site to load instantly. Don’t be a hoarder. Be a curator. Your stack should be elegant, minimal, and powerful. Like your brand.

Digital Cleaning Service?

We perform Tech Stack Audits, App Consolidations, and Middleware Implementations.

Hire our Architects.